Why I Decided to Test 7 Canadian Credit Cards at the Same Time

The Problem With Most Best Credit Card Canada Lists

Let me be straight with you. Last January I was sitting at my kitchen table in Toronto with seven different credit cards fanned out in front of me like I was about to do a magic trick. I had a spreadsheet open, a coffee going cold, and genuinely no idea which one of these cards I should actually be using every day.

The problem? Every “best credit cards in Canada 2025” article I found online read like it was written by someone who had never actually used the cards. The same four cards kept appearing. The same affiliate-driven rankings. Zero real numbers from real spending.

So I decided to run the test myself — twelve months, real purchases, every dollar tracked.

The 7 Canadian Credit Cards I Tested — Full Lineup

From No-Fee Basics to Premium Travel Cards

Cards Selected to Cover Every Canadian Spending Profile

I chose these seven to represent every major category of Canadian credit card available in 2025. Some cost money annually. Some are completely free. Some are built for travel. Some are built for groceries. Here’s the full lineup:

• American Express Cobalt Card — Best for dining and grocery spend in Canada
• Scotiabank Gold American Express — Best for travel points accumulation
• TD Cash Back Visa Infinite — Strong for everyday grocery and gas spending
• CIBC Dividend Visa Infinite — One of Canada’s top cashback credit cards
• RBC Avion Visa Infinite — Flexible travel redemptions across multiple programs
• BMO CashBack World Elite Mastercard — Category-leading grocery cashback
• Tangerine Money-Back Credit Card — The best no-fee credit card in Canada

■ Pro Tip: Before applying for any credit card in Canada, check your credit score for free through Borrowell or Credit Karma Canada. Most premium cards require 660+ and top-tier cards prefer 700+.

Month-by-Month Testing: What the Real Numbers Showed

Tracking Groceries, Gas, Travel, Dining and Online Shopping

Why Category Bonuses Matter More Than Base Earn Rate

Here’s the insight that changed how I thought about the best credit card strategy in Canada: the category bonus multipliers matter far more than the base earn rate. A card offering 5x points on groceries absolutely crushes a flat 2% cashback card if groceries are your biggest monthly spend category.

My monthly spending averaged $900 on groceries, $250 on dining and restaurants, $180 on gas, $200 on online subscriptions, and $400 on miscellaneous purchases. Over twelve months, that’s significant money flowing through these cards — and the difference in rewards earned between the best and worst performers was over $600.

The grocery category was the single biggest differentiator. Cards with 3–5% back at Canadian grocery stores (Metro, Loblaws, Sobeys, No Frills) accumulated rewards at a rate that flat-rate cashback cards simply couldn’t keep up with.

If you do nothing else after reading this article, figure out how much you spend monthly on groceries. That number will tell you which card wins for your wallet.

The Best Canadian Credit Cards Ranked — After 12 Months of Real Spending

1st Place: American Express Cobalt — The Best Everyday Credit Card in Canada

Why This Card Won the Best Credit Card Canada 2025 Test

After tracking every dollar for twelve months, the American Express Cobalt Card came out on top for my lifestyle — and I genuinely didn’t see that coming when I started. The numbers were clear: 5x points per dollar on food and drink purchases in Canada (restaurants, cafes, food delivery apps, and grocery stores), 2x on travel and transit, and 1x on everything else.

On my spending pattern, that translated to roughly 28,000 Amex Membership Rewards points per month — worth approximately $280–420 depending on how you redeem them. Over twelve months, that’s well over $3,000 in rewards value from a card with a modest monthly fee structure.

The points transfer to Marriott Bonvoy, Aeroplan, British Airways Avios, and several hotel programs — giving you flexibility that pure cashback cards can’t match. And the Amex Front of the Line presale access, Amex Offers program, and the travel and purchase protection are genuine perks that add real value beyond the points.

■ Pro Tip: The Amex Cobalt uses a monthly fee ($12.99/month = $155.88/year) instead of an annual fee. This means you can cancel any month without losing a full year’s fee — giving you more flexibility than annual-fee cards.

Runner-Up: Best Canadian Credit Cards by Spending Type

Top Travel Credit Card in Canada — Scotiabank Gold Amex

For the frequent traveller, the Scotiabank Gold American Express Card earns the title of best travel credit card in Canada for 2025. The 3x points on dining, groceries, gas, and transit, combined with exceptional travel insurance coverage and no foreign transaction fees, make it a card that pays for its $120 annual fee easily.

The Scotia Rewards points transfer to Aeroplan at a reasonable rate and can be redeemed for flights, hotels, and car rentals at a fixed redemption value that makes budgeting predictable — something points programs with variable redemption values don’t always offer.

• Best Overall: American Express Cobalt — for high grocery and dining spenders
• Best Travel Card: Scotiabank Gold Amex — for frequent flyers and international travelers
• Best Cashback Card: CIBC Dividend Visa Infinite — 4% on groceries and gas
• Best No-Fee Card: Tangerine Money-Back — 2% in up to 3 categories, forever free
• Best for Costco: CIBC Costco Mastercard — accepted where Amex isn’t

How to Choose the Right Credit Card for You in Canada — 4 Questions to Ask

The Credit Card Selection Framework That Actually Works

There’s no single best credit card in Canada for everyone — the right card depends entirely on your spending habits, travel frequency, and how much complexity you’re willing to manage.

Use these four questions to identify which card wins for your wallet:

• What are your top 3 spending categories every month? Groceries, gas, dining, subscriptions, travel?
• Are you willing to pay an annual fee? A $120 fee only makes sense if the rewards exceed it — most premium cards need $1,200+ annual spend in bonus categories to justify the fee.
• Do you travel internationally? If yes, look for no foreign transaction fee cards. This alone saves 2.5% on every purchase made outside Canada.
• Do you prefer cashback or points? Cashback is simpler; travel points offer higher value if you fly business class or stay at premium hotels.

■ Pro Tip: Apply for new credit cards when your credit score is above 700 and you haven’t applied for any new credit in the past six months. Multiple applications in a short period lower your score temporarily.

Final Verdict: Best Credit Cards in Canada in 2026 — The Honest Summary

Stop Leaving Rewards on the Table with the Wrong Canadian Credit Card

After twelve months of real-world testing, the conclusion is clear: the best credit card in Canada for most people in 2025 is the American Express Cobalt Card, particularly if you spend heavily on food, restaurants, and delivery.

For travellers, the Scotiabank Gold Amex wins. For simplicity and no annual fee, Tangerine Money-Back is unbeatable.

The average Canadian leaves $400–600 in unclaimed rewards on the table every year by using the wrong credit card — or worse, a debit card — for everyday purchases. That’s real money.

Apply for the right card this week, redirect your existing spending, and let your credit card do what it’s supposed to do: reward you for money you were already going to spend.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best credit card in Canada for cashback in 2026?

The CIBC Dividend Visa Infinite offers 4% back on groceries and gas — the highest combined rate at those categories of any major Canadian bank card. For a no-fee option, the Tangerine Money-Back Card gives 2% in up to three categories of your choice.

Is the American Express Cobalt Card worth it in Canada?

Yes, for anyone spending $500+ per month on groceries and dining combined, the Amex Cobalt Card earns rewards that significantly outpace its monthly fee. The 5x points on food and drink is the best earn rate at those categories of any personal credit card in Canada.

What credit score do I need for a premium credit card in Canada?

Most premium Canadian credit cards (Visa Infinite, World Elite Mastercard, American Express) require a credit score of 660–700+. Cards like the Amex Platinum or RBC Avion typically prefer 720+. Check your score for free at Borrowell or Credit Karma Canada before applying.

Can you have multiple credit cards in Canada?

Yes. Many financially savvy Canadians carry 2–3 cards strategically — typically one for grocery and dining rewards, one for travel, and one no-fee everyday card.

The key is paying the full balance monthly to avoid interest, which eliminates all rewards earned.

Read more:

Best Places To Visit In Brampton: 5 Amazing Spots You Must Explore

best credit cards Canada
2025 top Canadian credit cards
cashback credit card
Canada
travel rewards card
Canada
no fee credit card Canada
best rewards credit card
Canada Amex Cobalt Canada
CIBC Dividend Visa
Canada